|
Post by grimgor on Aug 12, 2017 6:26:56 GMT
Did you konw if it work with the EDBT ? Does this rough terrain increase his speed ?
|
|
|
Post by grimgor on Aug 7, 2017 13:09:04 GMT
So I have played a few games and still find the original Dommy3 list really strong into SR17.. Not sure about when the point values change though. Only solution I can see is to drop the MK? Do we have anyone with ideas or playing different lists? B. Thank you for this feedback, on which scenarios were you playing ? Standoff seems to be the worse for a doomy 3 full beast list. Spred the net doesn't seems to be so good too as you don't really want to break the brick. And do you think all kolgrimma in PoD could replace doomy 3 ? I haven't tried her yet but she seems to be really strong but she don't really do the same thing that doomy 3
|
|
|
Post by grimgor on Aug 4, 2017 8:59:11 GMT
Having only the stone for unit may be an issue for some scenarios. You really think playing a full beast list is still a good idea with this SR 2017 ? FOr example if you play on outlast i guess you would take your other list, but this will be the obvious choice that your opponent will expect, and for me this is disturbing.
|
|
|
Post by grimgor on Aug 1, 2017 12:58:18 GMT
then you play her in BoH Well yes, I think so. Need to see her on the table though. Yes for the moment its only ideas, we will see, anyway kolgrimma is denying magic and shoot, it could be enough even without RFP but idk
|
|
|
Post by grimgor on Aug 1, 2017 12:32:32 GMT
And dont you think kolgrima is a good drop in PoD ? Feat is denying shooting too and have mulg with arcane vortex and you have owl's Wlsdom against parasite and crippling grasp. It seems to be a nice drop too It's the lack of RFP which is the problem. Other than that it's an excellent cryx drop. then you play her in BoH
|
|
|
Post by grimgor on Aug 1, 2017 6:47:58 GMT
And dont you think kolgrima is a good drop in PoD ? Feat is denying shooting too and have mulg with arcane vortex and you have owl's Wlsdom against parasite and crippling grasp. It seems to be a nice drop too
|
|
|
Post by grimgor on Jul 26, 2017 12:09:38 GMT
But SoTN dont have access to warders where BoH can. And i think SoTN don't seem to have good options against gunlines. What's your mind on this ?
|
|
|
Post by grimgor on Jul 11, 2017 9:06:37 GMT
I dont understand why 6 points, maximus is 4 points and looks very similar design... I'd argue that Valka offers a different niche. His focus is punishing your opponents approaching and hurting you, and raw survivability (feign death, rise and unyielding) means he's a pretty tough cookie. Whether or not he is worth a full 6 is unclear but he'll be quite the freebie in Northkin theme. Yes i'm ok with this, but sometimes using countercharge could be a trap, it's not an ability which is easy to use. But if You can counter charge, use righteous vengeance with his good attacks, that could be interessant for his threat range and his potential of destruction, but i'm not sure a good player will let doing that, it should come from a missplay often. That's a guy who want to use madrak 2 's feat
|
|
|
Post by grimgor on Jul 10, 2017 22:11:57 GMT
I dont understand why 6 points, maximus is 4 points and looks very similar design...
|
|
|
Post by grimgor on May 26, 2017 9:58:31 GMT
I'm a bit suprised cryx drop ghost fleet into troll and besides against BoH, which have the tools to play against. They weren't playing skarre 1 in your meta ? (which is a real issue for troll and doomy 3 for my mind) And for me skarre is one of the best cryx caster. What would be your PoD grissel list ? WIth PoD, u will have for sure fewer attacks, why do you think it's better for the attrition game ? It's a real pleasure to share opinions with you, i learn a lot, it will be for sure useful for my future games
|
|
|
Post by grimgor on May 26, 2017 8:49:25 GMT
Thanks for this detailled answer ! I played doomy 2 a bit, and i noted that people didn't expect how far you can go, and then they aren't enough careful and dont take measures. But for me the real threat range against heavies spam are 12' as u can't play rush and rage at the same time. I played yesterday a doomy 2 list with 2 EDBT, 2 mauler and mulg against amon. i think it was properly a no-match as i can't handle enliven with parry (fortify that you can't hex blast so no head bot). I thought doomy 3 should have been better on this matchup. Do you think you can play grissel 2 on this match up ? I believed that deafen didn't work on leader if u kill him, i was wrong ? In fact if u kill the leader of one unit, the new leader can't give orders ? For the toby's match against khador on youtube, do you know why he didn't play doomy 3, it should have been correct against vlad 1 no ? And do you know the macths he plays against cryx (and won it), i'm very interested in, as i have problems to play against them. I feel in your feed back that you were going often on assassination run with grissel 2 because u can't win it with a different way. This seems to be a little disturbing for the faction. And as we are talking about it combo smite on youtube just upload a doomy3/Strakhov2 matchup won by doomy 3 And otherwise i hope my english is enough understandable
|
|
|
Post by grimgor on May 26, 2017 6:20:48 GMT
I played a doomy3/madrak3 on a team tournament, but i did regret it as there is obvious counters (mortality for example...), so i prefer your pairing. And on this tournament i encounter a grim 2, this was very annoying. Do you know why he played 3 lights with his madrak 3 list and why did he make these choices ? (i understand your meta was with ghost fleet, but is there anothers reasons ? (And if he were the first troll on this master, i think he was right.) I forgot that u can play the stone for denying stealth, as i was thinking that u can't sacrifice the stone for it, but you made 2 KTC thanks to that, so i will remenber this On your denny 1 game, Were you all in when u went on KTC ? Do you think u can still play attrition game against her with your grissel list and even winning ? Do you think Doomy 2 has a place instead of doomy 3 ? But i think doomy 3 is better in much situations. I really like your write up for the last game, it should have been an intense game. Didn't you want to play doomy 3 in all cygnar matchups ? Thank you for your answer.
|
|
|
Post by grimgor on May 25, 2017 23:11:40 GMT
Thanks for your report i did read it all, and it was very interesting. I saw the match Khador/troll with Toby nathan on your youtube, do you know which list did he pair with madrak 3 ? (very strange list without any heavy beast)
|
|
|
Post by grimgor on May 24, 2017 7:47:48 GMT
Would u still playing the same doomy 3 list in SR 2017 ? I play exactly the same list but i swap the storm troll for runeshapers, for some presence on scenario. I don't play the EDBT but a mauler, because implacability is doing the same thing that his animus.
|
|
|
Post by grimgor on May 24, 2017 7:40:12 GMT
Are u still playing the same list u showed at the begining of the thread ? How are u playing the list without ADR ?
|
|