She's just not for me I'm afraid, I think there's too much stuff going on and I forget things like phantasms till it's too late. The child does a similar job but much more straight forward. Plus my dice are well known locally to be poor (it's a running joke that for me an average roll off to dice is 5), so power 23 takes dice out of the picture.
I was going for something a little different with the witch list. I've no idea how good it is and it may be better with more heavies, however I like the potential -6 defence and if I can get wraith bane up to I can send a rattler into a haley3 trencher cloud wall and do some serious munching!