|
Post by Charistoph on Feb 12, 2018 22:36:35 GMT
For a quick run-down, I put all the numbers of Flamigant's post in to Excel to get some ranking information.
For popularity (most run), it goes: 1) Amon - 77 Games 2) Vindictus - 58 Games 3) Thyra - 23 Games Severius2 - 23 Games 5) Durst - 20 Games 6) Reznik2 - 19 Games 7) Harbinger - 18 Games 8) Kreoss1 - 12 Games High Reclaimer - 12 Games 10) Kreoss3 - 11 Games 11) Testament - 10 Games 12) Feora3 - 8 Games 13) Severius1 - 7 Games 14) Feora2 - 5 Games Reznik1 - 5 Games 16) Malekus - 4 Games 17) Feora1 - 3 Games 18) Durant2 - 2 Games 19) Kreoss2 - 1 Game
But their success rate is a little different: 1) Feora1 - 100.0% Durant2 - 100.0% Kreoss2 - 100.0% 4) Feora3 - 87.5% 5) Kreoss3 - 72.7% 6) Vindictus - 72.4% 7) Testament - 70.0% 8) Thyra - 69.6% 9) Harbinger - 66.7% 10) Severius1 - 57.1% 11) Amon - 55.8% 12) Reznik2 - 52.6% 13) Kreoss1 - 50.0% 14)Durst - 45.0% 15) Severius2 - 43.5% 16) High Reclaimer - 41.7% 17) Feora2 - 40.0% Reznik1 - 40.0% 19) Malekus - 25.0%
That success rate doesn't tell a whole story, though. None of the most successful have had more than 5 games, after all. Let's see if we do a combined score, giving the most games a higher rank number, as well as the success rate a higher rank number and adding them together. Not the best ranking system, but it is something.
1) Vindictus - 32 2) Thyra - 28 Amon - 28 4) Kreoss3 - 25 5) Feora3 - 24 Harbinger - 24 7) Testament - 22 Reznik2 - 22 9) Durst - 21 Severius2 - 21 11) Feora1 - 20 12) Durant2 - 19 13) Kreoss2 - 18 Kreoss1 - 18 15) Severius1 - 17 16) High Reclaimer - 15 17) Feora2 - 7 Reznik1 - 7 19) Malekus - 5
Just some interesting things to note. Vindictus seems to be the best out of the ones posted here because of the decent rate of success (42/58 games won), but Amon is the most popular (77 games over all). Thyra has a better success rate, but has been played in fewer games than Amon has lost to.
Now, are those numbers from effectiveness of the Warcaster to the scenario or the comfort that the players have with them, or both? Poor Kreoss2 has only been played in one game, but whoever played him, played him well enough to win! Malekus, however got stomped like a bug, having few games and even fewer successes (1/4 games won).
Have fun, everyone!
|
|
|
Post by HighPaladin on Mar 9, 2018 9:28:04 GMT
Won a 30 man event with Harbinger/Amon:
Amon = 44-34 (won vs Dreamer) Durst = 9-11 Durant2 = 2-0 Feora1= 3-0 Feora2 = 2-3 Feora3= 7-1 Kreoss1 = 6-6 Kreoss2 = 1-0 Kreoss3 = 8-3 Malekus = 1-3 Reznik1 = 2-3 Reznik2 = 10-9 Severius1 = 4-3 Severius2 = 10-13 High Reclaimer = 5-7 Testament = 7-3 Harbinger = 15-6 (won vs Kreuger2, Elara2, Vlad1) Thyra = 16-7 Vindictus = 42-16
|
|
moquan
Junior Strategist
Posts: 193
|
Post by moquan on Mar 21, 2018 10:21:30 GMT
Updated
|
|
|
Post by correlion on Mar 21, 2018 12:16:17 GMT
My results from local team tournament:
Amon = 47-34 (won vs Dummie3, Kraye, Witch Coven) Durst = 9-11 Durant2 = 2-0 Feora1= 3-0 Feora2 = 2-3 Feora3= 7-1 Kreoss1 = 6-6 Kreoss2 = 1-0 Kreoss3 = 8-3 Malekus = 1-3 Reznik1 = 2-3 Reznik2 = 10-9 Severius1 = 4-3 Severius2 = 10-13 High Reclaimer = 5-7 Testament = 7-3 Harbinger = 15-6 Thyra = 17-7 (won vs Ossyan) Vindictus = 42-16
|
|
|
Post by HighPaladin on Apr 9, 2018 14:38:52 GMT
Testing a variety of Exemplar Interdiction + Revelator lists with High Reclaimer currently,
6-0 with the archetype so far, all of which were primary wins via attrition:
HR vs Grim 1 (Storm of the North): Assassination win HR vs Aurora (Clockwork Legions): Scenario win HR vs Siege 2 (Storm Division): Assassination win HR vs Locke (Destruction Initiative): Time win HR vs Madrak1 (Storm of the North): Scenario win HR vs Coven (Scourge of the Broken Coast): Assassination win
Amon = 47-34 Durst = 9-11 Durant2 = 2-0 Feora1= 3-0 Feora2 = 2-3 Feora3= 7-1 Kreoss1 = 6-6 Kreoss2 = 1-0 Kreoss3 = 8-3 Malekus = 1-3 Reznik1 = 2-3 Reznik2 = 10-9 Severius1 = 4-3 Severius2 = 10-13 High Reclaimer = 11-7 (Won vs Grim1/Aurora/Siege2/Locke/Madrak1/Coven) Testament = 7-3 Harbinger = 15-6 Thyra = 17-7 Vindictus = 42-16
|
|
|
Post by HighPaladin on Apr 16, 2018 8:19:41 GMT
Had a 6 round event with a High Reclaimer (Exemplar)/Harbinger (Faithful Masses) pairing. Finished 5-1 and 3rd.
Round 1: HR vs Thyra (Guardians): Time Win Round 2: Harbinger vs Gorten (Hammer Strike): Scenario Win Round 3: Harbinger vs Madrak1 (Storm of the North): Scenario Win Round 4: HR (mine) vs Harbinger (Faithful Masses): Assassination Win Round 5: HR vs Morghoul2 (Disciples of Agony): Scenario Loss Round 6: HR vs Haley3 (Grave Diggers): Time Win
Also, one more normal game with HR: HR vs Haley3 (Grave Diggers): Assassination Win
Amon = 47-34 Durst = 9-11 Durant2 = 2-0 Feora1= 3-0 Feora2 = 2-3 Feora3= 7-1 Kreoss1 = 6-6 Kreoss2 = 1-0 Kreoss3 = 8-3 Malekus = 1-3 Reznik1 = 2-3 Reznik2 = 10-9 Severius1 = 4-3 Severius2 = 10-13 High Reclaimer = 15-8 (Wins vs Thyra, Harbinger, Haley3, Haley3. Loss vs Morghoul2) Testament = 7-3 Harbinger = 17-6 (Wins vs Gorten & Madrak1) Thyra = 17-7 Vindictus = 42-16
|
|
|
Post by HighPaladin on Apr 26, 2018 8:59:19 GMT
I may as well keep updating here - hopefully more people will start filling this in again Also, I want to keep people informed about what an absolute boss High Reclaimer in Exemplar Interdiction is (with a Revelator). Now 14-1 with the archetype! Game 1: HR vs Deneghra1 (Slaughter Fleet): Scenario Win Game 2: HR vs Amon ad Raza (Creator's Might: Scenario Win Game 3: HR vs Asphyxious 1 (Scourge of the Broken Coast): Assassination Win Game 4: HR vs Haley3 (Gravediggers): Scenario Win Amon = 47-34 Durst = 9-11 Durant2 = 2-0 Feora1= 3-0 Feora2 = 2-3 Feora3= 7-1 Kreoss1 = 6-6 Kreoss2 = 1-0 Kreoss3 = 8-3 Malekus = 1-3 Reznik1 = 2-3 Reznik2 = 10-9 Severius1 = 4-3 Severius2 = 10-13 High Reclaimer = 19-8 (Wins vs Denghra1, Amon, Asphyxious1 and Haley3) Testament = 7-3 Harbinger = 17-6 Thyra = 17-7 Vindictus = 42-16
|
|
moquan
Junior Strategist
Posts: 193
|
Post by moquan on Jun 3, 2018 7:42:09 GMT
Long time now update, sorry guys, real life I guess.
Got back to Protectorate and played 15 games (Nordisch Masters, local steamroller, and some practice games for the tournaments) and went 7-8. Not too bad after playing a different faction for half a year I would say.
Amon (3-5), wins vs Kreuger2/Heretic/King of Nothing, losses vs Denny2/Vlad2/Rask/Harkevich/Doomy3. HR (1-1), win vs Sorcha3, loss vs Siege1 (had to prevent listlock in the 6th round dropping Amon would also be bad. His other list was Haley3 2xlances). Kreoss3 (2-1), wins vs Jarl/MacBain, loss vs Thyra. Harby (1-1), win vs Thyra, loss vs Ossrum.
|
|
|
Post by cgdeth on Jun 4, 2018 11:44:42 GMT
Amon = 50-39 Durst = 9-11 Durant2 = 2-0 Feora1= 3-0 Feora2 = 2-3 Feora3= 7-1 Kreoss1 = 6-6 Kreoss2 = 2-1 Kreoss3 = 10-4 Malekus = 1-3 Reznik1 = 2-3 Reznik2 = 10-9 Severius1 = 4-3 Severius2 = 10-13 High Reclaimer = 20-9 Testament = 7-3 Harbinger = 18-7 Thyra = 17-7 Vindictus = 42-16
K2 EI (non-CiD) into Farrow Helga.
Managed to stay up on scenario then Helga failed her Assassination run leaving K2 on 4 HP 1 focus.
2nd game with K2 Played vs Minions Gatormen lost on a long drawn out attrition game. Played the dumbbell scenario.
|
|
|
Post by HighPaladin on Jun 8, 2018 8:31:05 GMT
Quite a few more games to put in here now, including 7 from Welsh Masters. With High Reclaimer (Exemplar Interdiction) and Harbinger (Faithful Masses), unless otherwise stated. Total Score: Harby (10–2), HR (4-2), Rez2 (0-1)
HR vs Borka2 (Storm of the North): Assassination Win HR vs Barnabus 2 (Will Work for Food): Assassination Loss HR vs Haley 3 (Gravediggers): Scenario Win HR vs Issyria (Defenders of Ios): Scenario Win Harbinger vs Skarre 1 (Dark Host): Scenario Win
Welsh Masters Round 1: HR vs Kreuger 1 (Call of the Wild): Scenario Win Round 2: Harbinger vs Bradigus (Bones of Orboros): Scenario Win Round 3: Harbinger vs Asphyxious 3 (Black Industries): Scenario Win Round 4: Harbinger vs Harbinger (Faithful Masses): Scenario Loss Round 5: Harbinger vs Old Witch 2 (Jaws of the Wolf): Assassination Win Round 6: HR vs Dreamer (Dark Menagerie): Scenario Loss Round 7 Harbinger vs Grim 1 (Storm of the North): Time Win
Harbinger (CID Exemplar Interdiction) vs Asphyxious 3 (Black Industries): Scenario Win Harbinger (CID Exemplar Interdiction) vs Haley3 (Gravediggers): Scenario Win Harbinger (CID Exemplar Interdiction) vs Haley3 (Gravediggers): Assassination Loss Reznik2 (Faithful Masses) vs Haley3 (Gravediggers): Scenario Loss Harbinger vs Skarre1 (Slaughter Fleet): Scenario Win Harbinger vs Rahn (Forges of War): Scenario Win Harbinger vs Barnabus 2 (Will work for food): Scenario Win
Amon = 50-39 Durst = 9-11 Durant2 = 2-0 Feora1= 3-0 Feora2 = 2-3 Feora3= 7-1 Kreoss1 = 6-6 Kreoss2 = 2-1 Kreoss3 = 10-4 Malekus = 1-3 Reznik1 = 2-3 Reznik2 = 10-10 (Loss vs Haley3) Severius1 = 4-3 Severius2 = 10-13 High Reclaimer = 24-11 (Wins vs Borka2, Haley3, Issyria, Kreuger1. Losses vs Barnabus2, Dreamer) Testament = 7-3 Harbinger = 28-9 (Wins vs Skarre1, Bradigus, Asphyxious3, Old Witch2, Grim1, Asphyxious3, Haley3, Skarre1, Rahn, Barnabus2. Losses vs Harbinger, Haley3) Thyra = 17-7 Vindictus = 42-16
|
|
|
Post by polymonith on Jun 8, 2018 18:59:24 GMT
Amon = 50-39 Durst = 10-11 (FM Win vs Gaspy3) Durant2 = 3-0 (FM win vs Venethrax) Feora1= 3-0 Feora2 = 2-3 Feora3= 7-2 (FM loss vs JagaJaga) Kreoss1 = 7-6 (EI win vs Dreamer) Kreoss2 = 2-1 Kreoss3 = 10-4 Malekus = 1-3 Reznik1 = 2-3 Reznik2 = 10-10 Severius1 = 4-3 Severius2 = 10-13 High Reclaimer = 24-11 Testament = 7-3 Harbinger = 28-9 Thyra = 17-7 Vindictus = 42-16
|
|
Choco
Junior Strategist
Gorten, best feet in the game.
Posts: 571
|
Post by Choco on Jun 8, 2018 19:14:59 GMT
Got two wins with Sevvy1 in FM.
Amon = 50-39 Durst = 10-11 Durant2 = 3-0 Feora1= 3-0 Feora2 = 2-3 Feora3= 7-2 Kreoss1 = 7-6 Kreoss2 = 2-1 Kreoss3 = 10-4 Malekus = 1-3 Reznik1 = 2-3 Reznik2 = 10-10 Severius1 = 6-3 Severius2 = 10-13 High Reclaimer = 24-11 Testament = 7-3 Harbinger = 28-9 Thyra = 17-7 Vindictus = 42-16
|
|
Choco
Junior Strategist
Gorten, best feet in the game.
Posts: 571
|
Post by Choco on Jun 15, 2018 16:28:51 GMT
Got another game in with my Sevvy1 FM list, this time against Sturm and Drang (S&D) with a Dracodile. Not being able to charge the Dracodile is super annoying. I came close to tabling my opponent. This is weird as he is one of our top players and has been a boogeyman for me for a long time. Also found it interesting that was able to get both of my Champions into S&D. He conceded when the second one walked over to engage him and he had no more beasts to transfer to. People that were watching the game are still questioning why Menoth isn't played more often. I'm questioning why Sevvy1 seems to not be played very often. Also, almost one-shot Wrongeye with a charge from an Idrian. That would have sealed a scenario win for me instead of the caster kill/concession.
Amon = 50-39 Durst = 10-11 Durant2 = 3-0 Feora1= 3-0 Feora2 = 2-3 Feora3= 7-2 Kreoss1 = 7-6 Kreoss2 = 2-1 Kreoss3 = 10-4 Malekus = 1-3 Reznik1 = 2-3 Reznik2 = 10-10 Severius1 = 7-3 Severius2 = 10-13 High Reclaimer = 24-11 Testament = 7-3 Harbinger = 28-9 Thyra = 17-7 Vindictus = 42-16
|
|
moquan
Junior Strategist
Posts: 193
|
Post by moquan on Jun 15, 2018 19:38:46 GMT
Could you post your Sevvy1 list?
|
|
Choco
Junior Strategist
Gorten, best feet in the game.
Posts: 571
|
Post by Choco on Jun 15, 2018 19:39:52 GMT
|
|